Lammy was asked in the Commons today as he talked up the need to spend more on defence whether it might be a good idea to spend the £18 billion the UK has earmarked for its Chagos surrender on the armed forces instead. The Foreign Secretary wasn’t keen on answering that one…
Labour also refused to conduct a national security impact assessment on the deal – overseas territories minister Stephen Doughty instead says the negotiated agreement “protects and secures” UK/US national security interests by keeping the base on Diego Garcia running. Shadow armed forces minister Mark Francois tells Guido the “Chagos chaos continues and is now in danger of becoming a threat to our national security and that of our allies, including the United States. That’s why we tabled a question asking the Foreign Office to conduct a specific assessment of the national security implications of the Chagos deal, aside from just the cost – which at up to £18 billion is completely daft anyway.” Almost the size of the ‘black hole’…
A national security impact assessment would cover major disruptive risks and policy like Chagos’ transfer would be in its remit. It would assess live concerns Guido reported over the nuclear weapons held on Diego Garcia – which are at risk from Mauritius having signed the Africa Nuclear Weapon-Free Zone Treaty – as well as the capability of Mauritius to defend the military base once the archipelago is its sovereign territory. There is also a massive question mark over whether the UK would be able to use the islands for its own defence purposes independently of the United States. Would be good to know…
Mauritian PM Navin Ramgoolam is now being urged by his politicians to demand more money from the UK for the deal. Take it out of the defence budget…
Herbert Raymond McMaster has been talking to Policy Exchange this afternoon about foreign policy. McMaster served as US National Security adviser in the first Trump administration from 2017 to 2018. He spoke about the Chagos deal:
“In 2017-2018 I came to the conclusion that the Chagos deal would be a travesty. It would put us at a significant strategic disadvantage especially at a time when China is trying to take control of critical choke points. This is why President Trump has a legitimate concern over both sides of the Panama Canal, say. It’s just a really bad idea to give up sovereignty to organisations that can be subverted and turned against their purpose.”
Chagos would be quite the choke point to have in China’s sphere of influence. All eyes on team Trump…
Attention is increasingly turning towards the judges responsible for providing 2019’s advisory ICJ opinion on the Chagos Islands – the legal insecurity which Starmer uses as his only justification to hand over the islands. And adherence to which is purely voluntary…
One of the judges, Xue Hanqin, was a Chinese state official and diplomat prior to joining the ICJ. She wasn’t the only one…
Another judge to support the 2019 opinion was Kirill Gevorgian. Formerly of the USSR/Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Gevorgian was appointed by Putin as Russia’s ambassador to the Netherlands back in 2003 – a role he occupied until 2009. Hanqin happened to be China’s ambo there from 2003 to 2008…
After leaving his ambassadorial role Gevorgian returned to Moscow to serve as the legal director for the Russian foreign ministry. He has received four state awards from Putin, including a certificate of honour in 2011 “for active work to protect the interests of the Russian Federation.” Gevorgian voted in 2023, along with Hanqin, against an ruling that Russia should suspend its invasion of Ukraine…
His awards in full:
China and Russia are both very keen on the Chagos surrender deal and it was only a judge from the United States supported the UK in that 2019 advisory ruling. Is Starmer about to hand our enemies their biggest joint legal victory yet…
Starmer’s close friend Philippe Sands KC has acted as chief legal counsel to Mauritius on the Chagos deal for years – it is actually his shaky legal opinion on the “electromagnetic spectrum” at Diego Garcia that Downing Street is hiding behind in its insistence the surrender has to go ahead. Satirists are going out of work at an unprecedented rate…
Beijing Barry Gardiner has invited Sands to chat about the Chagos deal – on which the CCP is undoubtedly keen – on the 25th of this month at his APPG for Climate, Nature & Security in parliament’s Portcullis House. An invitation says the “Chagos negotiations are a complex combination of post-colonial justice, environmental policy, and global security interests, with a wide range of implications for marine conservation, climate resilience, and regional stability” and “world experts” including Sands will “frame the issue and support a deeper understanding of the integrated security concerns.” Mauritius for its part has dismissed existing environmental protections for the Chagos Islands as unnecessary…
Mauritius is an ally of China – its total cumulative investment is around $1 billion. No doubt Sands, who planted a Mauritian flag on Chagos without permission, will present a ‘balanced’ case for the country’s eco-credentials…
Read the full invitation below:
Continue reading “Beijing Barry Invites Philippe Sands to Parliament to Discuss Chagos Surrender”
The Chagos surrender deal is in complete chaos. Yesterday the Mauritian PM announced he had managed to get significant additional concessions out of the UK government on Chagos. Ramgoolam said the new deal he had managed to get frontloaded payments from the UK and linked them to inflation, as well as imposing the requirement for a Mauritian veto on any possible 40-year extension on the UK’s lease of Diego Garcia. Trigger complete panic mode in Whitehall…
Downing Street refused to comment on the possibility that the UK could now pay £18 billion to hand over Chagos – the FCDO then put out a punchy statement overnight saying Ramgoolam’s claims were “entirely inaccurate and misleading.” Starmer defended the deal at PMQs by suggesting that there was some secret national security reason for handing the base of which Badenoch hadn’t bothered to apprise herself. At a subsequent briefing it was clarified this related to the advisory ICJ ruling – no detail was provided on whether there was new legal advice since Labour came to power. Cameron saw the advice and killed the deal…
Now the Mauritians have issued a communique, no doubt under pressure from panicking officials in the UK, clarifying Ramgoolam’s grandstanding. It claims “Mauritius has never said that the financial package in the agreement between Mauritius and the UK on the Chagos Archipelago had doubled” and new negotiations “have clarified and firmed up the unequivocal understanding that any extension would need to have the consent of Mauritius and the UK.“ A partial rollback…
In the meantime government insiders are finally starting to brief against the deal itself after realising how bad it looks and are pointing the finger at international law-obsessed Richard Hermer. The Chagos deal has become a constantly exploding catherine wheel – all while the actual decision sits with Team Trump over in DC. You have to laugh…
Read the Mauritian communique below:
Continue reading “Chagos Deal Thrown Into Chaos As Mauritius Rolls Back on Payment Claims”
Peter Hitchens isn’t a fan of Grand Theft Auto VI:
“Once we have filled our skulls with this sort of liquid manure, we have lost a vital part of our souls. I was perfectly serious when I suggested a church visit. This electronic poison undermines 2,000 years of Christian civilisation.”