Here’s an argument for a May election – if Hope is the word (and it made 10 appearances in PMQs) he can’t leave it for a year. Hope has an expiry date. Hope goes off, like ham. What was aromatic becomes sulfurous and slimy (there are comparisons in there, best unexpressed).
Hope is what the Downing St team comes up with when PMs ask for life-changing policies that don’t cost anything.
And so we have, hope for young people. Giving young people hope because a million young people have no hope. “The Tories took hope from a generation. We will give it back to them.” And most ambitiously, “This side of the House is letting Britain believe again and bringing back hope.”
Alongside “There is no national security without social security,” Andy Burnham is “letting Britain believe again.”
Dear Lord, this politics of “Clap if you believe in fairies” is bad enough to work.
As Burnham doubles down, how is Kemi dealing with the evolving situation?
The PM must have had a confidence-building week. He had been fumbling and bumbling and stumbling over his delivery and his amused opponent established an early dominance. Now, he has collected himself. His socialist sincerity has been boosted to 11. The Chamber rang with it. You can see him getting through an early election with it.
Brown bottled his, Theresa braved hers, both were ruined by it.
How can Kemi pre-ruin Burnham?
Time will do that, but for now . . . (this maybe asking too much) we do need some concise, cogent capsules of conservative thinking.
Her exposition of youth unemployment under the Tories is a case in point. She told us it fell by 7% between 2011 and 2021 – but then Covid, but anyway, “that 7% is more than all the savings that they’re going to find to help young people from the Milburn review.”
Fair enough, but what that does most for your sketchwriter is to impress upon him the speed and voracity of his cognitive decline.
“He keeps talking about all of the government schemes that they’ve got. The youth guarantee scheme is a complete and total failure. Everyone out there knows it. They destroy jobs, they kill businesses and then they offer the businesses a little money to give young people work placements. It makes no sense at all.”
Those of us who believe this sort of thing already can easily become confused. What is the youth guarantee scheme? Is it a total failure? Does everybody know that and why don’t I know? This “they” who destroy jobs, who are they? Does it literally make no sense at all? Isn’t there some sense, some Labour sense, some socialist sense which makes perfect sense? Giving money to voters to make them more likely to vote for you, isn’t that sensible for politicians? And if not, why not?
Anyone with the inclination will play along with her assertions, but she is a bit early on the credibility curve to ask us to take it on faith. When she says, “The cost of hiring a young person has gone up by almost £5,000 under Labour,” she gives us a fact out of which a whole political philosophy can be spun.
The more expensive things are, the less people get them. It is the Conservatives’ job to explain to the voting public that demand curves generally slope down to the right. That will need a bit of poetry, a bit of humanity, a voter-motivating, election-winning demolition of socialism in five words or less. We really need that from Mrs Badenoch. We really need a reason to believe a conservative temperament is necessary, successful and above all, attractive.
I remember reprimanding Minister Michael Gove for the Tories’ inability to come up with this sort of statement. “Slogans?” he said. “I can tell you what I think.” So, the problem is longstanding.
Having said that, Kemi’s mockery is effective. She laughed at the PM’s 10-year plans for NATO as well as Welfare – everything takes 10 years under Burnham – he’ll be far from the scene of the crime when time is called. There was the charge that working-age welfare was some amazing number of billions rising to a larger number of billions. And she also had an amusing swipe at the current hierarchy of the government:
“Keir Starmer failed to make welfare cuts because this Chief Whip (Annaliese Midgley) and that First Secretary of State (Louise Haigh) led the rebellion on welfare. Now they’re in charge of the Labour Party.”
All well and good, but my Tory heart was still left in a jar by the door waiting for a jump start.
Mail commentator Dan Hodges – who was kind to Burnham during the Makerfield campaign – now concludes: “The truth is Andy Burnham doesn’t have a 10 year plan. He’s barely got a 10 week plan.“