Walk through this Brexit ‘mythbusting’ document, just published by the government, with Guido:
Why is the UK Government building a closer relationship with the EU?
- We are working to deliver practical deals that pay off for British businesses and families, which will be agreed at the UK-EU Summit on 20 November:
- A youth experience scheme with the EU will create new opportunities for young people to live, study and travel on the continent. We are in the middle of a youth unemployment disaster…
- A ‘food & drink’ trade deal could add up to £5.1 billion a year to our economy, cutting back on paperwork for businesses and easing pressure on prices. That’s a higher-band figure for 2040, leaves out costs for firms that don’t trade with the EU, CropLife estimates that herbicide and fungicide losses will cost farms £800 million per year, the Fresh Produce Consortium says there will be an additional £300 million cost to supply chains, Britain can remove export certificate fees if it so chooses, the figure also counts savings from removing EU import checks that Labour itself chose never to bring in…
- Our emissions linking agreement could add up to £3.8 billion a year to our economy, and protect critical industries like steel and aluminium from a ‘carbon tax’ (CBAM) on approximately £6.5 billion in exports. The Brussels carbon price is higher than ours, Lords have found there would be extra £200-300 million a year for the electricity deal, alignment also means joining ETS2, the EU’s carbon tax on petrol, diesel and boiler gas, steel import costs would rise from £30 tariff to £150, a remainer Lords committee has found the electricity deal benefit would be “small or even negative”…
Will the UK rejoin the European Union, and will it cost British taxpayers millions?
- The Prime Minister has been clear that the UK Government remains committed to its ‘red lines’ for the remainder of the Parliament. Rayner promised that Labour would ‘never’ campaign to rejoin any of the three core elements of the EU, which Burnham has shredded now by saying he could try to take Britain back in…
- This explicitly rules out rejoining the EU, the customs union, or the single market, as well as returning to freedom of movement. Emissions Trading System linkage means Britain signs on to Customs Union rules for manufactured goods…
- Any cost-related figures circulating are based on hypothetical scenarios, are largely speculative, and are not reflective of the UK-EU Summit package. So are Labour’s…
Will British taxpayers have to pay millions of pounds into the EU budget?
- No. There will be nothing in the UK Government’s Sanitary & Phytosanitary (SPS), Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) and Youth Experience Scheme (YES) deals that will require UK taxpayers to pay into the EU budget. The Treasury said on 13 November: “discussions have begun on the EU’s proposal to establish a mechanism for a UK financial contribution towards reducing economic and social disparities between the regions of the Union as part of participation in the Internal Electricity Market”…
- As is standard in international agreements, the UK Government has always been clear that both sides will pay proportionate contributions for the running costs associated with the functioning and administration of the agreement (such as shared IT systems and databases). This is different from paying into the EU’s budget. And costs tens of millions and is negotiated…
Will smoky flavours in crisps, sauces, and soups be banned in the UK?
- No. This is inaccurate. Smoky flavours in crisps, sauces, and soups will remain on UK supermarket shelves. But they will not be allowed to be labelled as such…
- Most British crisp makers adapted their recipes years ago in order to continue selling into Europe. EU regulations are set to restrict meat-related labels, which means smoky bacon crisps will have to be renamed or removed…
Will British marmalade need to be relabelled as “citrus marmalade” or list specific citrus fruits?
- British marmalade will not need to be relabelled, as most British marmalade brands on supermarket shelves already meet European labelling rules, so they can sell into Europe. Citrus spreads must be sold as “citrus marmalade” or carry the fruit’s name, such as “lemon marmalade”, the EU only allows non-citrus spreads to be called marmalade…
Will the EU deal mean a ban on single-serve sachets of ketchup, mayonnaise, sugar, salt, oil, and vinegar in the UK?
- No. Single-serving sachets and containers are not part of the UK Government’s Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) deal.
- Any future decisions about packaging waste in the UK will be made domestically by the UK Government. Which means the government will ban them anyway and will definitely do so before any future deal, as Guido always said…
Did the UK waste billions building border infrastructure after Brexit?
- New UK border facilities are actively protecting UK biosecurity today while negotiations continue and until the Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) deal is implemented. Would only be a waste if Burnham pushed Britain back to the EU with this deal…
Will the UK be forced to stop sending foreign national prisoners back to the European Union?
- No. The UK has not agreed to stop deporting or transferring foreign national prisoners to the European Union. This does not mention early removals and the government has so far committed not to proceed with the removals of EU offenders under this year’s deport-on-sentencing changes…
Will British taxpayers pay for roads, airports, and green energy facilities in poorer EU member states?
- No. There will be nothing in the UK Government’s Sanitary & Phytosanitary (SPS), Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) and Youth Experience Scheme (YES) deals that will require UK taxpayers to pay into the EU budget. Erasmus+ will cost Britain around £570 million in 2027, the “Farage clause” means paying compensation if a future government pulls out of the food deal, in March the EU authorised talks on a permanent contribution from Britain…
Will UK food products no longer need to display “Not for EU” warning labels?
- Yes. Once fully implemented, the UK-EU Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) deal will remove the vast majority of “Not for EU” labels. Because Britain adopts the harsh EU rules the labels were policing…
- Removing these labels will strip away needless trade friction between Great Britain and Northern Ireland, lowering costs for British supermarkets and food producers. Savings only on goods shipped to Northern Ireland, and alignment will cause new friction by breaching CPTPP and the Australia and New Zealand deals…
Will British produce like nuts, fruit, vegetables, and blended honey require more detailed country-of-origin labelling?
- Many British exporters already follow these international labelling standards when exporting to the EU, so this will not represent a new shock to producers. The ones that don’t will be dragged into compliance for extra cost…
- Clearer labels also provide more transparent information to consumers. Not exactly mythbusting, is it?
Will the UK-EU Summit package ban non-USB-C phones, detachable bottle caps, or single-use plastics like straws, cutlery, cotton buds, and polystyrene cups?
- No. None of these retail or consumer electronics rules are part of the UK’s new agreements with the EU. No one said they were…
Did leaving the EU cause the small boat crossings?
- While leaving the EU is not the sole cause of small boat crossings, the UK Government’s view is that leaving made tackling the issue harder by reducing access to intelligence and returns mechanisms. The Dublin agreement brought 1,215 people into Britain and sent 209 out in 2018…
- Leaving the European Union reduced the UK’s access to shared EU security information on those crossing the Channel, removed existing mechanisms to return migrants, and meant the UK has had to focus on negotiating new bilateral agreements – including with France, Belgium, and Germany. European countries are now going to send migrants to Rwanda as Britain could have done on its own…
- No one is saying leaving the EU is the sole reason behind small boat crossings, and the Prime Minister has been clear that this is not an excuse to avoid taking the necessary action to secure and restore control to the UK’s borders. But he has heavily suggested it numerous times…
Hogwash…