The government is scrambling to justify its deeply unpopular Chagos surrender deal as Starmer touches down in DC, insisting the agreement must go ahead to safeguard UK-US military operations on Diego Garcia. In the Commons last night, FCDO minister Anneliese Dodds dutifully claimed the deal is necessary to maintain access to critical satellite communications:
“Without a negotiated solution with Mauritius, it would pursue its legal campaign. We would unfortunately see international organisations following that determination, such as the International Telecommunication Union, [which] could be that critical spectrum for telecommunications that is essential for our security is compromised.”
The problem? This directly contradicts the government’s own official position. In response to a written question, DSIT minister Chris Bryant confirmed that the International Telecommunication Union has no power to veto military spectrum and cannot interfere with satellites. Shadow armed forces minister Mark Francois tells Guido:
“Last night saw a very lively, opposition inspired debate in the Commons on the Government’s surrender deal, during which Ministers repeatedly refused to say either what the deal would cost or whether the new increase in defence spending would be used to pay for it. The Government’s case for the deal keeps constantly shifting and now the FCDO are completely at odds with DCMS over whether there is a legal threat to satellite communications from the base, via the International Telecommunications Union (ITU). This Chagos chaos cannot continue. Let’s hope Trump puts Starmer out of his misery on this – in which case the extra money announced for Defence could actually be spent on Defence, instead of being given to Mauritius.
Labour’s justification for the sellout doesn’t add up…
Science Secretary Peter Kyle was sent out on the media round this morning after David Lammy admitted last night that the Chagos deal wouldn’t go ahead without Donald Trump’s approval. The surrender deal is just one of many areas where Starmer and Trump don’t see eye to eye…
Appearing on GB News, Kyle was asked whether Lammy’s revelation was remarkable, given Labour’s relentless push for the sellout. He dismissed the suggestion, insisting it was “perfectly obvious” that the US would have a say in the matter. He doubled down earlier, adding that it would be “very, very odd if we acted unilaterally.” Pressed on whether the deal is “dead in the water” given Trump’s opposition—along with that of key advisors and Marco Rubio—Kyle notably avoided a denial. Instead, saying: “The important thing is what comes out of these discussions, not the rhetoric that goes into them.” Tough times for Starmer in DC…
Downing Street has been working overtime ahead of Starmer’s big White House trip tomorrow – a Downing Street source describes the preparations as “chaotic” since Monday. The PM has prepared by talking up his ‘bridgeist’ approach to Europe and Trump’s US and stopping Labour short of any criticism of Trump’s various statements. Walking on a tightrope…
Starmer’s favourite Airbus A321 is now departing from Stansted and will land at Camp Springs in Maryland in about nine hours. The PM will hope his defence spending boost will help him curry favour with the US president for tomorrow’s evening joint press conference…
Stateside sources tell Guido Starmer could hit a roadblock in his talks with Trump thanks to Labour’s ill-fated Chagos surrender. The deal, the cost of which ministers and Starmer have refused to confirm will not be baked into boosted defence spending, is hated by members of Trump’s team and vocal Republican senators in Washington. Trump, who is aware of the deal, may well bring it up publicly tomorrow. A block is what some in the government secretly hope for – but not then, not there…
Badenoch asked Starmer at PMQs if he could confirm that “none of the defence uplift includes payments for his Chagos deal.” A highly pertinent question since yesterday which no minister has been able to answer…
“The additional spend I announced yesterday is for our capability on defence and security in Europe as I made absolutely clear yesterday – the Chagos deal is extremely important for our security, for US security – the US are rightly looking at it. When it’s finalised we’ll put it before the house with the costings.”
Kemi pressed him on the same point and got the reply: “The money announced yesterday is going to our capability to put ourselves in a position to defend the security of our country Europe and the UK.” Tory MP Kieran Mullan also asked the same question and got the same answer. The opposite of ruling it out….
Shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick has published a 7-minute explainer video on X explaining why the Chagos deal is a terrible idea. Not entirely sure what that has to do with the justice brief…
The video goes through the history of the territory as well as following Guido’s reporting on the links between Hermer, Starmer, and Philippe Sands. The three chums running both sides of the negotiations…
Meanwhile John Healey has refused to say if the billions to be given to Mauritius for the deal will come out of the newly-uplifted defence budget. Which would put the fanfare over the extra spending in perspective…
On LBC Nick Ferrari asked defence secretary John Healey if “the £9 billion to lease back the military base” on the Chagos Islands will come out of the defence budget.
“Well there will be no payments unless and until the deal is struck.”
He was asked four more times and repeatedly dodged the question: “I’m not going to get into hypotheticals, the figures, if there is a deal, will be laid before parliament. The details will be laid.” Doesn’t sound encouraging…
Reports from Port Louis have suggested that the British government is willing to pay £18 billion to hand over the islands, a large sum of which would be front-loaded. Healey was meanwhile challenged on the Today Programme and LBC about Starmer’s dodgy maths – the government is still insisting the uplift is worth £13 billion. As the IFS has pointed out the real increase to the defence budget will be £5-6 billion by 2027. Asked which figure was accurate Healey said: “It’s both.” The cost of leasing back a base we already own could then absorb almost four times as much as Starmer’s ‘landmark’ defence spending hike – from the budget for that hike…
UPDATE: Healey’s shadow James Cartlidge says: “Yesterday the PM said defence spending was rising by £13.4bn. Today his Defence Secretary says £6bn. Which is it? Kemi Badenoch was only given a redacted version of the PM’s statement before he spoke, missing all the figures. Transparency matters & we urgently need clarity.”
Peter Hitchens isn’t a fan of Grand Theft Auto VI:
“Once we have filled our skulls with this sort of liquid manure, we have lost a vital part of our souls. I was perfectly serious when I suggested a church visit. This electronic poison undermines 2,000 years of Christian civilisation.”