The government is repeatedly blocking minutes of a meeting held last year between Attorney General Richard Hermer and Mauritius’ chief legal adviser on the Chagos Surrender Philippe Sands. The Attorney General’s Office has been in regular communication with Philippe Sands with regard to its determination to withhold the details…

The minutes of the meeting in November last year – at which the UK’s candidate for the ICJ Dapo Akande was also present – were originally blocked under S36 of the FOI Act which claims the release of the information would “prejudice — the maintenance of the convention of the collective responsibility of Ministers of the Crown… or would be likely to, inhibit the free and frank provision of advice.” Guido can reveal the Attorney General’s Office gave Starmer’s close friend Philippe Sands advance warning of this with a private offer to him to “raise any factors or considerations” for the blockage of information by the Solicitor General. A total of seven emails were exchanged in relation to the meeting as well as a phone call…
After the FOI was blocked Richard Hermer’s SpAd reached out to Sands by telephone to discuss “a related query from a journalist.” Sands reassured the AGO: “As you will be aware, I do not comment on such matters, and will not comment if asked about the meeting.“ Curious…
Dapo Akande previously sided with Mauritius in its claim to the Chagos Islands – Akande supported the International Court of Justice’s 2019 ruling that the UK should hand the islands back “as swiftly as possible,” even calling the case a “decolonisation” project. To work so extensively to block the minutes of a meeting on 13 November between the three to “discuss international law and the International Court of Justice” is not typical. Unless Chagos was discussed – was it?
Chagossians will be palmed off to three civil servants for “future programmes” with the FCDO after the Chagos Surrender. Guido doubts they will be thrilled…
Labour insisted on 8 July that the government recognises “the importance of the islands to Chagossians and have worked to ensure the agreement reflects this” along with providing additional support to them. To that end Stephen Doughty said “a new ‘Contact Group’ will facilitate dialogue between the Chagossian community and the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office on future programmes.” Chagossians campaigned vociferously against the surrender deal…
As of 15 August there has been no first meeting of the Contact Group, according to information acquired via Guido’s FoI Unit. The FCDO says it will be chaired by a deputy director – the lowest rung of the senior civil service and the only senior official running the Group. Previously ministers met with Chagossians…
The secretariat for the contact group will be only two junior civil servants – a Grade 7 “supported by” an even more junior higher executive officer who will be working “alongside other responsibilities.” Guido does not envy them – they will be getting an earful if they gather the courage to actually have a meeting…
Freedom of Information requests fired by the Tories have discovered the actual cost of the Chagos Surrender deal: £34.7 billion in nominal terms. Guido has the full figures…
Starmer and ministers claimed – including in the Commons – that the cost would be £3.4 billion “calculated using the Treasury’s rules.” That is using “Net present value” calculations which are almost never used by the government to explain costs or funding. Guido and others pointed out at the time that this was tosh and the accurate figure was over £30 billion…
Figures laid out below show the actual figure was reduced to £10 billion to account for 2.3% inflation – then forced down again using something known as the “Social Time Preference Rate” which is a Treasury tool to frontload the stated value of spending. The figure Starmer peddled is 90% lower than the actual funds to be handed over…
Badenoch said this morning: “Starmer betrayed public trust by misrepresenting the real cost, which will fund tax cuts in Mauritius. Now tax rises are coming to pay for this nonsense. When Labour negotiates Britain loses.“ Thank goodness Mauritians get their income tax cut…
Read the full Tory FOI releases below:
Continue reading “FULL FIGURES: Actual Cost of Chagos Surrender Deal is £35 Billion”
Guido hears from DC insiders that the disastrous – and eye-wateringly costly – Chagos sellout is not fully settled Stateside. As The Heritage Foundation’s eminent Nile Gardiner wrote yesterday: “the Chagos issue is not over in Washington, and major red flags are being raised in the United States.” Now a route has emerged via which the deal could be slowed down or even scrapped…
The powerful House Appropriations Committee has now raised the issue directly with Marco Rubio. The Committee is Republican-led and is sound on Chagos. A relevant passage from the current State Department appropriations Bill states:
“United Kingdom and Chagos Archipelago —The Committee notes that with the growing challenge from the PRC the military facilities on the island of Diego Garcia are central to Anglo-American power projection and relative control of the Indian Ocean. Recognizing the invaluable strategic importance and geographic relevance of Diego Garcia to the United States, the Committee encourages the Secretary of State to engage with His Majesty’s Government of the United Kingdom to ensure our long-term access to the facilities and that they remain integral to allied security.”
These reports have been corroborated and furthered by Guido’s high level Capitol Hill sources, who say that the deal may well be torn up by Trump. The President has been angered by recent free speech crises in the UK, which became very clear to him during his Scotland trip…
Moreover, Vice President Vance is understood to be monitoring the issue carefully. He’s in the UK this summer. Guido will have more soon…
Labour has failed in writing to provide evidence for Starmer’s claim that China, Russia, and Iran are against the Chagos surrender deal. Starmer twice misled the house on the matter…
Asked in a written parliamentary question by Priti Patel to provide the “evidential basis he said that (a) China, (b) Russia and (c) Iran are opposed to the treaty with Mauritius.” A straight question…
Answer came there none from FCDO ministers. Overseas territories minister Stephen Doughty said:
“The deal to secure the base on Diego Garcia is vital for our national security.
Our Five Eyes allies – the US, Australia, New Zealand, Canada – as well as India, South Korea and Japan, all put out formal statements welcoming the deal.
There are clear safeguards in the treaty, including a clear prohibition to prevent any other foreign security forces, civilian or military – including the Chinese – from establishing themselves on the outer islands.”
A tacit admission that the repeated claim is bogus. Patel tells Guido:
“Instead of coming clean and apologising, Starmer is now refusing to answer questions and provide evidence to back up his claims. The fact that he couldn’t be bothered to answer the question himself and his junior minister’s response failed to back up his claims goes to show that you can’t believe a word Keir Starmer says. The truth is that China, Russia and Iran back his Surrender Treaty as it makes Britain weaker and Keir Starmer backs the Treaty as he puts the demands of left-wing lawyers and activists above the national interest.
Having spent years lecturing us that ‘honesty and integrity’ matter in politics, it’s scandalous that Keir Starmer is refusing to explain the claims he made to the British people and to Parliament.”
China praised the deal…
Overseas territories minister Steve Doughty is up before the Foreign Affairs Select Committee in the Commons now to talk about the Chagos surrender deal. Asked about the costs of the deal he congratulated himself on the government’s transparency so far:
“It’s not normal to provide the costings but in this case we have decided to for the benefit of transparency on this deal and particularly because some of the misleading commentary that was going on around them, the government green book methodology has been used over all of this and if the committee wants I can take you through the very complex arguments behind it but essentially it averages out at 101 million per year.”
Actual cost: £30.3 billion. About a minute and a half after Doughty congratulated himself for his party’s commitment to transparency by publishing basic cost details of the surrender he was asked what amount the MoD would pay and the FCDO would pay:
“So there will be a share between the two departments but I’m not not able to give that that at this stage.”
There goes the transparency. A large amount will obviously go out of the “boosted” defence budget straight towards relieving Mauritian citizens of the need to pay income tax…
Doughty tried some spin: “Even if the MoD was paying the full amount here – which it isn’t – it’s just a fraction of 1% of the total annual defence budget, and one thing here that we’ve got to remember is that the value to us of this facility is as I said quite frankly priceless but it’s it’s certainly significant multiples of the investment that’s put in.” Priceless – ironic considering the terms of the surrender…
Peter Hitchens isn’t a fan of Grand Theft Auto VI:
“Once we have filled our skulls with this sort of liquid manure, we have lost a vital part of our souls. I was perfectly serious when I suggested a church visit. This electronic poison undermines 2,000 years of Christian civilisation.”