38 peers wrote to attorney general Richard Hermer to warn that recognition of Palestine as a state may break international law thanks to the 1933 Montevideo Convention which sets out conditions for statehood:
The peers – made up of legal experts from both parties – include respected lawyer Lord Pannick and tell Hermer: “You have said that a selective ‘pick and mix’ approach to international law will lead to its disintegration, and that the criteria set out in international law should not be manipulated for reasons of political expedience.” Good point…
This morning business minister Gareth Thomas attempted to claim it wasn’t a legal question:
“In the end, recognition of another state is a political judgment and over 140 countries have already recognised Palestine… there is a clear population… we have made clear that we think you would recognise the state of Palestine, and that state of Palestine would be based on the 1967 borders.”
To base current statehood on conditions that existed in the past is a novel interpretation of the convention. As expected there are increasing numbers of anonymous briefings from angry pro-Israel Labourites, especially at Starmer’s decision to put conditions on Israel, which is illogical. Hermer will find it difficult to get out of this one…
Lucy Powell told Sky News that the Ed Miliband-Russell Brand interview happened in part because the ‘social media age’ had not begun by 2015:
“Look, I mean, he approached the Labour Party, he approached the campaign team, and we’re in very different times now. We weren’t in the social media age at the time – where you could maybe search things up and see allegations about somebody at the time. and as I say, if there was any suggestion at all, we were dealing with someone who was a known sexual predator at the time, then, of course, you know, no one would have done that. But as I say, he was a well known public figure. Lots of people from Hollywood to the BBC to many others gave this person a very, very powerful platform. And we didn’t know at the time, unfortunately. It was a different era.”