The Institute for Fiscal Studies says of the main Milburn report proposal:
“There are two key risks to delivering on the plans. First, it is difficult to scale up support quickly. History shows that delivering large increases in apprenticeship numbers, such as the additional 100,000 a year the Review envisages, can be difficult. The previous Conservative government fell well short of its apprenticeship targets between 2015 and 2020. Many employment support schemes have also struggled to deliver the planned number of places.
Second, the support might not be as effective as the Review hopes it will be. Employment support programmes have a mixed record. The Review’s own modelling anticipates that its proposals would bring an extra 440,000 into work, bringing the NEET rate to 7% by 2036, slightly short of their target.
It is difficult to judge the plausibility of these modelled employment effects based on the limited detail in the report. But employment increases of this scale are far from guaranteed and would hinge on the effectiveness of the programmes proposed.”
Other think tanks have views too:
- Silvia Andreoletti, Head of Communications at the ASI: “At a time when 3 in 4 constituencies spend more in welfare than receive in tax from workers, the reforms proposed today are nowhere near enough. The savings wouldn’t actually begin for three years, but during that time welfare spending will have increased by nearly £100 billion a year. The £14 billion savings over 10 years promised by the report pale in comparison to the ballooning costs… The report also didn’t touch on the other major hurdle stopping employers from hiring young people: the minimum wage increases.”
- Policy Exchange: “The proposals to reduce the cost of hiring young workers are welcome but to not go far enough. The Government needs to urgently reverse the hike in employers’ National Insurance Contributions that occurred in 2025, which has raised the cost of hiring workers from firms’ perspective to its highest level since 2011, even after adjusting for inflation and productivity gains.”
- Prosperity Institute: “Subsidies will not fix Britain’s youth unemployment crisis. They are fig leaves that barely disguise the damage the Government’s policies have wrought on the labour market. Vacancies have fallen to their lowest level since 2014, whilst youth unemployment remains stubbornly high at 15 per cent. Alan Milburn proposes paying businesses £3,000 to employ young people who have been NEET for six months.”
- Centre for Social Justice: “Britain’s welfare crisis does not end at the age of 25. Millions of older adults are stuck out of work and the bill is nearly £50 billion higher in real terms than in 2019. Milburn has shown a way forward but to pay for this expensive plan, meaningfully reduce the welfare bill and transform lives, ministers must find the courage to apply that ambition across the welfare system at large.”
Milburn after reading…