The Treasury is under renewed pressure to reveal the models behind its latest round of Project Fear forecasts, with a group of 26 economists including Remain and Leave supporters writing to Treasury Select Committee Chair Nicky Morgan, calling on her to demand that the Treasury makes its models available to “qualified independent economists”. Signatories to the letter include former external members of the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee, former economic advisers to government and the CBI and former Treasury officials. Not just the usual Brexiteer economist crowd…
The letter notes the “widespread unease about the very negative post-Brexit outcomes predicted by the Treasury’s economic model” and complains that the Treasury’s attempts to explain its approach have been impenetrable even to “experienced macroeconomists”. The Treasury’s black box figures are playing a huge role in the Government’s approach to Brexit, they should be subject to full independent scrutiny…
Read the full letter below:
The Rt Hon Nicky Morgan MP
Chair, Treasury Committee
House of Commons
London SW1A 0AA
Dear Ms Morgan
It is evident from both oral and written evidence submitted to the Committee that there is widespread unease about the very negative post-Brexit outcomes predicted by the Treasury’s economic model, as published on November 28th. While the Treasury made some effort to explain its approach, this explanation does not permit even experienced macroeconomists to understand how the model works and what the impact of alternative assumptions might be.
These economic projections have been a key part of the Government’s rationale for its Brexit proposal and are influencing this critical once in a generation debate. It is vital that Parliament and the public have an opportunity to understand the basis for the model’s conclusions in greater depth than afforded by the report and, particularly, how different assumptions to those used by the Treasury would alter the projected economic outcomes.
Therefore – as a broad group of economists with both Remain and Leave inclinations – we believe the Committee should discharge its responsibility for scrutiny by recommending that the Treasury make its model available to qualified independent economists who can review the Treasury’s conclusions and assess how different assumptions might change these conclusions.
If you are in agreement with this, we are available to advise on how this might best be organised.
We look forward to an early reply.
Professor Vudayagi Balasubramanyam – Professor of Development Economics, Lancaster University
Professor David Blake – Professor of Economics and Director of the Pensions Institute, Cass Business School
Roger Bootle – Chairman of Capital Economics
Michael Burrage – Director of Cimigo, former lecturer London School of Economics
Professor Tim Congdon CBE – Chairman Institute of International Monetary Research, University of Buckingham
Dr Ken Coutts – Emeritus Assistant Director of Research, Faculty of Economics, University of Cambridge
Shamik Dhar – Former Chief Economist, Foreign and Commonwealth Office
Professor Kevin Dowd – Professor of Finance and Economics, Durham University Business School
Charles Dumas – Chief Economist, TS Lombard
John Greenwood – Chief Economist, Invesco
Dr Graham Gudgin – University of Cambridge
Liam Halligan – Economist, broadcaster and Sunday Telegraph columnist
Andrea Hossó – Macroeconomist, public policy analyst, and former trade negotiator
Dr Ruth Lea CBE
Professor Graeme Leach – CEO & Chief Economist, Macronomics
Dr Gerard Lyons – Chief Economic Strategist, Netwealth Investments
Neil MacKinnon – Global Macro Strategist, VTB Capital
Professor Kent Matthews – Professor of Banking and Finance, Cardiff University
Douglas McWilliams – Deputy Chairman, Centre for Economic and Business Research
Edgar Miller – Convener, Economists for Free Trade
Professor Patrick Minford – Professor of Economics, Cardiff University
Paul Ormerod – Partner, Volterra Partners
Professor David Paton – Chair of Industrial Economics, Nottingham University Business School
Dr Andrew Sentance – Independent Business Economist, former External Member of the Monetary Policy Committee, Bank of England
Dr John Whittaker – Senior Teaching Fellow, Lancaster University