Kippers & Cybernats Most Stuck in Twitter Echo Chambers

Guido has written previously about how we are living in our own filter bubbles, both on social media and offline. Demos take us inside the echo chamber with their report “Talking To Ourselves”. The study confirms what many have observed for years: there is a huge echo chamber effect in political discussion online, meaning people tend to share and engage with news sources and individuals who share their own beliefs, and shun those with opposing views. Demos analysed the Twitter accounts of 2,000 users, finding:

“supporters of UK political parties tend to talk to themselves online, to read and share news that is ideologically in tune with their party and discuss issues on which they hold strong ideological views”

The research shows SNP and UKIP supporters have a particularly strong aversion to engaging with people or organisations who hold opposing views. Labour supporters are most likely to share links from the BBC, Guardian, Mirror, Indy and HuffPo. Tories seem less stuck in their echo chamber, sharing links from the BBC, GuardianTelegraph and MailAll groups tend shares news from sites aligned with their party affiliation – the further from the centre their affiliation, the deeper the echo chamber becomes…

This is replicated in the analysis of retweets. Labour, SNP and UKIP supporters retweet their fellow party supporters the vast majority of the time. Tories retweet fellow Tories less, though still more than they do anyone else. 

The data found @GuidoFawkes is the sixth most retweeted political site among the survey group, ahead of even the BBC and ITV. Unsurprisingly our retweeters are more likely to come from parties on the right:

The report concludes:

“Compromise, the ability to process a diverse range of opinion and, above all, an acceptance of some kind of shared reality and truth are central to a functioning democracy. All are threatened by the echo chamber effect.”

As our information sources become ever more filtered and self-socialised this will mean that we live in our own social media echo chambers. Is this a significant social problem? As we have seen recently, it means that after elections and referendums the losers are unpleasantly surprised…




Tip offs: 0709 284 0531
team@Order-order.com

Quote of the Day

A senior Brexiter:

“If Theresa and Julian have sold us out here they are in real trouble. She reassured us all at the 1922. There is no way she can recover if she has now fucked us over.”

Sponsors

Guidogram: Sign up

Subscribe to the most succinct 7 days a week daily email read by thousands of Westminster insiders.
Watch: AC Grayling Vs Andrew Neil Watch: AC Grayling Vs Andrew Neil
In Full: 103 Resignations Under Corbyn In Full: 103 Resignations Under Corbyn
Banks Legals Verhofstadt Over Putin Tweet Banks Legals Verhofstadt Over Putin Tweet
Hypocrisy of Chuka Hypocrisy of Chuka
Daily Brexit? Daily Brexit?
Claire Perry Accuses Bercow of “Sexist and Demeaning” Behaviour Claire Perry Accuses Bercow of “Sexist and Demeaning” Behaviour
Farage vs Verhofstadt Farage vs Verhofstadt
Watson Dodges Labour Live Watson Dodges Labour Live
WATCH: Andrea Jenkyns Takes on Remain Protesters WATCH: Andrea Jenkyns Takes on Remain Protesters
Philip Lee Resigns Philip Lee Resigns
Handshake That Made History Handshake That Made History
Sun, Mail, Telegraph Warn May Sun, Mail, Telegraph Warn May
LibDem Policy: It’s Transphobic to Call Ian Huntley Ian Huntley LibDem Policy: It’s Transphobic to Call Ian Huntley Ian Huntley
Penka Saved Penka Saved
WATCH: Corbyn Labour Live Sketch WATCH: Corbyn Labour Live Sketch
Guy News Special Report : Remain Campaign Cheating Guy News Special Report : Remain Campaign Cheating
Don’t Know Level With May Don’t Know Level With May
Geordie Greig New Mail Editor Geordie Greig New Mail Editor
No 10 Call DD Stupid No 10 Call DD Stupid