Tom Watson: Lobby System Against Public Interest
Lobby System Pinnacle of Implicit Politico-Media Corruption

Imagine a secretive organisation whose members have privileged access to Downing Street. Imagine that the members of this organisation receive information covertly. Imagine that the rules of this organisation force the members to withhold information from outsiders if the Prime Minister tells them so to do. Then consider that the members of this closed, opaque, secretive organisation are supposed to hold politicians to account on behalf of the public. After 208 years it is time to end the Lobby system.

The gentlemen of the Lobby drink in subsidised bars, from which the public are excluded, with the politicians they are supposed to hold to account on behalf of that same public. Cowardice and cronyism runs right through the Lobby because they are fearful of being taken off the teat of pre-packaged stories served to them.  That is not journalism, that is copy-taking, this blog was established in part because Guido believes the Lobby system fails the public. The Fourth Estate may not have a formal constitutional role, but the role is real. The role is not to produce “client journalism”.

Peter Oborne in his brilliant Triumph of the Political Class characterises the Lobby system as having produced a tame “client media”. He is absolutely right, the Lobby is far too cosily embedded in the politico-media system, far too close to their subjects, with the likes of Nick Robinson flashing his taxpayer-financed credit card to pour the better vintages down the throats of ministers who have their lunch on the BBC telly-taxpayers. The same ministers who had their expensed groceries sent to their mortgage subsidised home at the taxpayers’ expense. The system stinks, those who are supposed to be watching over politicians – journalists – and the politicians themselves, are the only ones who benefit from the system staying the same.

Two years ago the then PMOS, Simon Lewis, and the then chairman of the Lobby, Jean Eaglesham, announced that the system of Downing Street Lobby briefings was to be reviewed “in light of the changes in the reporting of the work of government in an increasingly fast-moving and on-line media world”. A working group of six lobby hacks and five government spin doctors was to come up with recommendations to be implemented last year. No one from the fast-moving online media world was on the working group. Did anything change? No.

Tom Watson has just called for an end to the Lobby system and off the record briefings. Cameron has said he supports all contacts between politicians and newspaper executives being a matter of public record. More transparency is clearly a good thing. That transparency should be applied to the Lobby system…

See also: In 2007 Guido filmed this polemic against the Lobby system for Newsnight:

Is Ed Miliband’s Ideological Guru the Third Kray Brother?

Watching Newsnight yesterday, post vajazzle, Guido was surprised to see they had on someone who looked and sounded like the third Kray brother; suit, hair and glasses all looked the part. It turned out that he was actually Ed Miliband’s new ideological guru, Maurice Glasman, of ‘Blue Labour’ fame. On the show a Labour MP sceptical of Blue Labour thinking suggested it was sexist and jingoistic. A bit like the Krays?

There are more similarities between Blue Labour and the Krays:

  • Emphasis on respectable working class culture.
  • Rooted in the community.
  • Both advocate non-voluntary protection rackets.
  • Small ‘c’ conservative.
  • Aspirational outlook.

Presumably Maurice loved his mum as well…

Guido’s Celebrity Super-Injunction Legal Advice

Yesterday Rod Christie-Miller, the CEO of Schillings and the lawyer who has made millions covering up the truth for billionaires and celebrities, told Newsnight’s Emily Maitlis that Guido might get “a knock on your door and a long time in Pentonville” for revealing the truth. We shall see…

Here is Guido’s legal advice to billionaires and celebrities:

A lot cheaper and more effective than Schillings’ advice…

Quote of the Day

Schillings’ Rod Christie-Miller tells Emily Maitlis that truth tweeters…

“You may find a knock on your door and a long time in Pentonville.”

Fortnum & Paul Mason

Look out for tonight’s Newsnight report from Comrade Mason who has spent the weekend sipping Molotov cocktails with Laurie Penny. For Mason these last few months have been an exciting period, reporting on a revolution which has Tweeted its way from Tahir Square to Trafalgar Square. Sometimes from dangerous territory with guerrilla protestors taking on tanks and now with those who think smashing up teacakes in front of old ladies is the moral equivalent.

Comrade Mason Live on the Frontline

Sometimes it has been as if he was broadcasting from Karl Marx’s bedroom – actually he did do that – embedded with friends this weekend his report should be an interesting exercise in straining impartiality. On his blog he let slip that: “At Fortnum and Mason the demonstrators who took it over are trying to get out, texting me…”. Above is our reconstruction of Mason in deep cover disguise this weekend…

Come Vote With Me

Last night’s Newsnight special hardly covered the referendum in glory, despite the best attempts of the BBC to nail their colours to their sleeve. With the headline “Majority want overhaul of voting system, poll suggests” you would have thought that it was good news for the Yes campaign, but get to the second paragraph of their story and you find: “63% of those polled said a referendum on changing the system is a waste of time and money when there are other pressing needs in the country.” Hmmm…

Jo Swinson did not help her cause last night with her strictly quite ridiculous suggestion:

On Twitter in the aftermath even her own side rejected the idea. Messy.

Paxman Does a Jeremy *#@*

Poor old Paxo doesn’t seem to have his heart in it any more – he is 60 – and he must be thinking are his 3-late-nights-a-week really worth the million-a-year he trousers?

The C-word came out last night on Newsnight. Once could be an accident, twice a coincidence, but this is third flagship BBC program to drop the c-bomb live on air in recent weeks. Do they have some sort of a bet going on?

Via : Political Scrapbook

Government Defence Organisation Sold Fake Bomb Detectors

Heydon Prowse has discovered that the UK Trade & Investment Defence & Security Organisation (UKTI DSO) was involved in the selling of millions of pounds of fake bomb detectors to foreign governments. Military personnel demonstrated dud products to gullible buyers. Heydon says the full story will be on Newsnight tonight…

Tories Astroturf Newsnight

On Tuesday’s Newsnight Paxman asked the audience of grassroots party members if any of them thought the child benefit announcement had been handled well. Only one person put their hand up to defend the Government…

But who was this  loyal […]


David Miliband Party Animal

Do you detect the influence of the editorial values of Guy News TV in last night’s Newsnight? Laura Kuenssberg is good enough to replace Emily Nomates…

Worth watching until the end for the focus group “David Miliband Party”. […]


Where’s the Cut?

Last night John Redwood flummoxed Kirsty Walk on Newsnight (here) when he said that the government was not cutting public expenditure. She didn’t really know where to go with her line of questioning since it was so off […]


Newsnight’s Olly Grendlestein Problem

Newsnight’s regular political panel, made up of Cameroon Danny Finkelstein, the LibDem’s Olly Grender and Blairite insider Peter Hyman, has a bit of a problem. Ever since the coalition emerged Grender and the Fink have moved closer and closer to […]


Tip offs: 0709 284 0531

Quote of the Day

Lord Sugar on Jeremy Corbyn:

“If they ever got anywhere near electing him and him being the Prime Minister then I think we should all move to China or somewhere like that and let this place just rot.”

Top Posts This Week

Guidogram: Sign up

Subscribe to the most succinct 7 days a week daily email read by thousands of Westminster insiders.


Charlotte Church Blames ISIS On Climate Change Charlotte Church Blames ISIS On Climate Change
It’s Zac It’s Zac
Friday Caption Contest: Sword Swallowing Edition Friday Caption Contest: Sword Swallowing Edition
Go Long Go Wrong Go Long Go Wrong
New.Spectator.Co.UK New.Spectator.Co.UK
Sturgeon Swerves Scandal Questions at FMQs Sturgeon Swerves Scandal Questions at FMQs

Max Mosley Bankrolled Tom Watson’s Deputy Leadership Campaign Max Mosley Bankrolled Tom Watson’s Deputy Leadership Campaign
1% of ConHome Readers Back Nimo For Leader 1% of ConHome Readers Back Nimo For Leader
EU Survey Finds Lancashire Loves Fracking EU Survey Finds Lancashire Loves Fracking
Corbyn: Nukes Didn’t Do USA Much Good Corbyn: Nukes Didn’t Do USA Much Good
Jeremy Snore-byn Jeremy Snore-byn
60,000 Flock Back to Uber 60,000 Flock Back to Uber
Hammond Warns of Climate Change Security Threat Hammond Warns of Climate Change Security Threat
Corbyn Dances as Stalin Looks On Corbyn Dances as Stalin Looks On
Zoe William’s Magic Money Tree Zoe William’s Magic Money Tree
Lefty Commentariat Pan Corbyn’s “Dire” Speech Lefty Commentariat Pan Corbyn’s “Dire” Speech
Corbyn Forgets The Deficit Corbyn Forgets The Deficit
Angela Eagle Turns The Airwaves Blue Angela Eagle Turns The Airwaves Blue
Public Flock to Back Uber Public Flock to Back Uber
BBC Helps Plug Big Solar BBC Helps Plug Big Solar
Mandy and McDonnell Shake Hands Mandy and McDonnell Shake Hands
Labour Speaker’s Gas Chamber Slur Labour Speaker’s Gas Chamber Slur
GCHQ Failed to “Sway” Judges GCHQ Failed to “Sway” Judges
Rudd Hands Over £5.8 Billion Climate Guilt Money Rudd Hands Over £5.8 Billion Climate Guilt Money
Corbyn’s Crazy Gang Corbyn’s Crazy Gang