SKETCH: Who is Responsible for the Energy Price Surge?

The hardest thing is getting them to admit the simplest things.

Margaret Hodge had the Treasury and the Department of Energy and Climate Change in to ask who is responsible for the great surge in energy prices and who is looking after consumers’ interests.

She didn’t question the departmental witnesses, but yelped at them in frustration, and then gazed with spaniel-eyed looks of reproach.

The water industry, she remembered, underspent one year by £1bn and with the regulator’s approval they gave the money out as a dividend, rather than put it into infrastructure. Why was that allowed to happen? Who allowed it? Why didn’t they do anything to stop it?

And now with energy costs having gone up by 40 per cent in real terms they were going up another 18 per cent to pay for infrastructure development. And median incomes had stayed flat for a decade. Hadn’t they. Hadn’t they! Hadn’t they? Yes, they had. Thank you.

The man from Energy and Climate Change, Simon Virley, said that the investment proposals weren’t actually regressive. The bottom 30 per cent of the population were “gaining most”.

Richard Bacon had heard something in the way Virley had put it: “You said the effect of the infrastructure will make it less regressive than they would otherwise have been. Are you saying they will be regressive?”

Virley shifted on his seat and started evasive tactics.

Bacon: (shutting his eyes to concentrate) “My question wasn’t ‘Who gains the most, and who gains to a lesser extent?’ Um, you used the phrase ‘less regressive’. That makes it sounds to me like – correct me if I’m wrong – that it will be regressive but it will be less regressive for those groups.” Got it! “Is that what you’re saying?”

Virley: (staring slightly): Well, I think I’m saying that it is actually a progressive package –

Bacon: “It’s very clear the difference between the two, and I just want to be clear in my own mind. ‘Less regressive’ and ‘progressive’ mean different things.”

Virley (leaning forward, smiling, with open hands): “The point I’m making is the total package is progressive because the lowest earners stand to gain the most.”

Bacon: “So, they’ll be better off than they are now.”

Virley: “I’m talking about the impact of Government policy.”

Bacon: “If it’s progressive, they’ll be better off than they are now.”

Virley: “Government policy is progressive. (Casting out a red herring) Of course if wholesale prices rise, if energy bills go up, that will hit lower income earners more.”

Hodge: “Are you saying the poorest 30 per cent will not have to pay any of this 18 per cent increase?”

Virley: “No, I’m saying when you take account of Government policy and the efficiency measures, it is progressive.”

Bacon: “It sounds like you’re saying it’ll be regressive but not quite as regressive as it might otherwise have been.”

Hodge: Quite. Why don’t you just say that?

Virley: Because that’s not what I think is the case.

Bacon: Do you think they’ll be better off than they are now?

Hodge: Will they pay less than they are now?

Virley: Er, n-no, they won’t be paying less than they are now . . . they gain the most in proportionate terms . . .

Poor people paying more for their energy, “gain the most in proportionate terms.”

This is the sort of struggle that democrats have “holding the executive to account” in the phrases they use.



Tip offs: 0709 284 0531
team@Order-order.com

GuidoFawkes Quote of the Day

David Cameron tells MPs after voting:

“Wouldn’t miss this for the world. Secret ballots very important. Remember the Chartists.”

Top Posts This Week

Guidogram: Sign up

Subscribe to the most succinct 7 days a week daily email read by thousands of Westminster insiders.

Facebook

WALTER MITTY CV OF ANTI-FRACKING CANDIDATE WALTER MITTY CV OF ANTI-FRACKING CANDIDATE
Cassetteboy v Cameron and Farage Cassetteboy v Cameron and Farage
MICROSOFT SHAKES DOWN PUBLIC SECTOR FOR DOSH MICROSOFT SHAKES DOWN PUBLIC SECTOR FOR DOSH
WATCH: Toby Young Skewers Labour Zero Hours Contract Attack Line WATCH: Toby Young Skewers Labour Zero Hours Contract Attack Line
MAIL TRICKED INTO QUOTING BATMAN FILM IN PLANE CRASH COVERAGE MAIL TRICKED INTO QUOTING BATMAN FILM IN PLANE CRASH COVERAGE
ANTI-FRACKING PARLIAMENTARY CANDIDATE WANTED TO WORK FOR FRACKERS ANTI-FRACKING PARLIAMENTARY CANDIDATE WANTED TO WORK FOR FRACKERS

Crick Gets Paxo’d Crick Gets Paxo’d
Cameron’s Secret A-List Cameron’s Secret A-List
Corrections and Clarifications: Brooks Newmark Corrections and Clarifications: Brooks Newmark
What is Wrong With the Lobby? What is Wrong With the Lobby?
Arrogant Bercow: “I’m Not Going Anywhere” Arrogant Bercow: “I’m Not Going Anywhere”
GOVERNMENT SHELLS OUT FOR PHOTO OF DEAD ZEBRA GOVERNMENT SHELLS OUT FOR PHOTO OF DEAD ZEBRA
DWP Press Office Wins the Internet DWP Press Office Wins the Internet
Two-Faced Chuka Ruins Labour Attack Ad Two-Faced Chuka Ruins Labour Attack Ad
Cameron Mauls Miliband at PMQs Cameron Mauls Miliband at PMQs
Actual Pub Landlord Likes Farage Actual Pub Landlord Likes Farage
Dave’s SNP Poodle Zinger Dave’s SNP Poodle Zinger
GREEDY SOLAR INDUSTRY WANTS MORE PUBLIC CASH GREEDY SOLAR INDUSTRY WANTS MORE PUBLIC CASH
This is the worst thing the LibDems  have ever done This is the worst thing the LibDems have ever done
CLIMATE CHANGE FUELLED MOSQUITOES ARE NOT COMING TO GET YOU CLIMATE CHANGE FUELLED MOSQUITOES ARE NOT COMING TO GET YOU
ORDNANCE SURVEY OPENS UP DATA MAPPING TREASURE CHEST ORDNANCE SURVEY OPENS UP DATA MAPPING TREASURE CHEST
“I’d S**k Off David Cameron” “I’d S**k Off David Cameron”
WATCH: Cameron Heckled By Pensioners WATCH: Cameron Heckled By Pensioners
WATCH: Gove v Campbell WATCH: Gove v Campbell
Politician dumps his wife over sexy selfies Politician dumps his wife over sexy selfies
UKIP PROTESTERS ORGANISED BY GREEN LOBBYIST UKIP PROTESTERS ORGANISED BY GREEN LOBBYIST
You’ve Been Cricked! You’ve Been Cricked!
He’s Not Dancing Anymore He’s Not Dancing Anymore
Miliband’s Hedge Funder Hypocrisy Miliband’s Hedge Funder Hypocrisy
NATIONAL TRUST CLAIMS CLIMATE CHANGE IS “BIGGEST THREAT” NATIONAL TRUST CLAIMS CLIMATE CHANGE IS “BIGGEST THREAT”