September 12th, 2013

‘Mad’ Mel Out at Mail, Dominic Lawson In

Melanie Phillips has left the Mail, Media Guido can reveal. She blogs:

The Mail want to shake up their Monday op-ed page and so I shall shortly stop writing my regular Monday column for them. Instead, they want me to write other major pieces. They say they are very keen that I should continue to have a significant presence in the paper. 

That’s certainly an option, although I have other plans for writing – and now, also, publishing. I am gratefully aware, though, from the many thousands of people who have written to me in passionate agreement over the years, that I have a very large following indeed among Daily Mail readers. Many write to me to say I am the only reason they read the paper (it’s enough to turn a girl’s head!) Only today, I was stopped at a Tube station by a woman who said: ‘I love your articles; don’t ever stop writing them’. 

I can promise her, and all my many followers, that I shall indeed continue to write them. As for where – well, watch this space.

It is understood that she will be replaced by Dominic Lawson.



  1. 1
    Talking of mad, an oldie but a goodie says:


    • 8
      Anonymous says:

      Typical Tory.

      Thick, ignorant and ugly.


    • 14
      your mum says:

      good, she is poisonous, hateful and generally wrong


      • 21
        Common Sense says:

        She looks very like the (fe)male version of a sandal wearing bearded lefty.


        • 33
          your mum says:

          that’s because she used to be one. like a militant ex smoker, she has gone mental in the other direction

          i find her an interesting and readable person i must admit, but she is usually wrong and hateful.


          • Aunt Mat says:

            And very predictable.

            You could probably write her column yourself.

            When a person becomes a parody of themselves, it is time to do something else.


      • 29
        Anonymous says:

        She is thoughtful, analytical, highly intelligent and generally right.


        • 37
          Just Saying says:

          Totally agree. You only have to listen to her on the BBC Moral Maze to see she puts those self glorying male leftists (usually the loony chairman of the SRA) into the shade on both wisdom and common sense.
          I must admit the Daily Mail is becoming more left of centre and the red arrows against centre right comments are sometimes alarming as with today.
          Is the DM into a big shake up and going to promote Red Ed – is the editor leaving???


          • FFS says:

            Daily Express outmanouvered the Mail on the EU, thus squeezing them over towards the left.


          • broderick crawford says:

            yeah i agree. at least she can string sentences together and turn them into logical pedagogical paragraphs be it in the written or verbal sense .

            right or wrong she expresses her views with conviction and without the mumbling cowardly caveats of weasel worded politicians always looking to avoid the next faux pas which could jeopardise their ascent up the “greasy pole ”

            ( or in lord fondleboys case the greasy poke )


  2. 2
    Labour...filth...just filth says:

    shes no loss


  3. 3
    Mikey P says:

    never mind Mel join me in casablanca, you can watch me daisy chaining with the local youths – they have such soft skin…


  4. 4
    The Prime Mentalist: Professional insanity for Britain says:

    A master at work…


  5. 5
    Conservatism says:

    There are no jobs for life


  6. 6
    Donald Rumsfeld says:



    • 43
      I know a cun't when I see it and it posts as blue anonymous says:

      You get one joo in and one joo out, shake it all about …


  7. 7
    Late says:

    Congratulations on revealing this only a few days late


  8. 9
    Anonymous says:

    Does ‘Dominic’ also find normal sexual behaviour strange and threatening?

    Or is he normal?


  9. 10
    Hacking victim of law firms and big business says:

    Concert in Hyde park saturday for the Peace in Syria campaign.Headlining are the

    Chemical brothers.


  10. 11
  11. 12
    The Tomintoul Conspiracy says:

    Has she been sacked but can’t admit it?


  12. 15
    Anon says:

    Perhaps she’s got a PR job at the Israeli embassy?


  13. 19
    Anonymous says:

    I think Mel is a fabulous,fearless and frank journalist. The Mail must be mad to let her go. Her left wing critics are not worthy of cleaning her shoes. Good luck,Mel.


  14. 20
    The Moral Maze says:

    Have you thought about writing for The Sun?


  15. 25
    Blowing Whistles says:

    Maybe she’s going back to her original Commie Marxist purpose roots – but her QT and very ott outburst revealed a lot about her.


  16. 28
    Cato Street Conspirator says:

    Strange woman. Does she dowse herself with Ajax after sex?


  17. 30
    Jimmy says:

    “Media Guido can reveal”

    It’s on her blog. What do you imagine you’ve “revealed”?

    “Instead, they want me to write other major pieces. They say they are very keen that I should continue to have a significant presence in the paper. ”

    And her pay is being “adjusted”?

    Too mad for the Daily Hitler. That’s got to sting. Give her a job Guido.


    • 50
      T.Ruth B Told says:

      Fuck me, that website your name links to is sick. I’ve just finished watching three hours of @nal spit roasts but your site is fucking horrendous. A load of sinister newspeak about new labour “progression”? Very fucking sinister. Before you accuse me of being a tory or a UKIP, don’t. I’m not. I’m an ordinary white working class bloke who fucking hates all the scum in Westminster, especially your Neo Labour bastards for utterly destroying working class communities in the UK. I urge people here to look at that site, it is a very telling signal as to what goes on behind the scenes of Red Ed and his PC arse lickers. Death to you all, a pox on your house and a curse on your ancestors.


    • 54
      jihadistguestcolumnists 'R'us bridger says:

      Ah The daily Hitler. I haven’t read the Graun for a while.


  18. 34
    Living in 97.222% white Merseyside says:

    She can talk sense but I tend to dis-like people who consider themselves intellectually superior.

    Think what a wake up call she would have had if she had lived in Vienna in 1938!


    • 41
      Comrade Trotsky says:

      Yes totally agree. I had to succumb to the superior intellectualism of Comrade Lenin, but did so willingly after a short war.
      Comrade Stalin was never our adversary in this internal conflict – he was inferior.


    • 42
      I know a cun't when I see it and it posts as blue anonymous says:

      A potato is intellectually superior to you, scouse.


    • 53
      truthers/ecoloons/psychotrots R us says:

      You must dislike most people then.


    • 61
      The Quiet Man says:

      Is not that event how she came to be Blighty born ?


  19. 35
    Border Terrier says:

    Mel is frank and fearless.. and totally bonkers if a little foxy too.

    Heard her speak at a Bruges Group Tory Fringe meeting a few years back – like being showered by paint stripper.


  20. 36
    Anonymous says:

    Shame, not! But good that she is leaving on such a modest note.


  21. 44
    Big Momma. says:

    Far more intellectual and readable than Pollytwaddle.
    Firm roots and does not suffer fools easily or wear her heart on her sleeve.


  22. 45
    bergen says:

    I think the Mail and the Grauniad should have swapped Mel and Polly for a month to see what it would do for their circulations (and the apoplexy rates of their readerships).


  23. 47
    Bigtime Friend of the Earth says:

    We fooled most of them, but she had to go.


  24. 49
    Paul Booth says:

    She used to be news editor of the Guardian! She follows the money.


  25. 52
    David Cameron Is A Cunt says:

    The Mail is slowly losing the plot and turning lefty in strange ways, especially mailonline.

    Swapping Melanie Phillips, who is generally interesting and correct in what she writes, for Dominic Lawson is rather like swapping Krug for sour milk that has gone off in the fridge.


  26. 55
    John says:

    Rumours that The Mail was not right wing enough for dear Melanie have been denied


  27. 64
    A sane person on this site?!? says:

    Ah the mad old bint was too right wing even for the Daily Fascist?

    God awful nasty reactionary.


  28. 65
    Nigel Farage doppelganger says:


  29. 68
    Anonymous says:

    She’s courageous, clever and correct.


  30. 69
    Anonymous says:

    Guido site comments = childish drivel. FGS you lot do some work and or get a job.


  31. 73
    Mrs Havisham says:

    Is Dominic Lawson another of Nigel Lawson’s brood?


  32. 75
    Oracle says:

    Dominic Lawson – snore!


Media Reader

John Humphrys Admits Skewed BBC Coverage | David Keighley
Bad News About News | Bob Keiser
When to Quit Your Journalism Job | Press Think
Guardian Looks Outside North London For New Editor | Media Guido
Guardian Staff’s Elite Schooling | Chris McGovern
Clodagh’s Law | Press Gazette
Meanwhile, in Russia… | Media Guido
Christmas TV Tips | Laura Perrins
All Star Line Up for New BBC Theme Park | David Keighley
City AM’s Kate McCann Joins The Sun | MediaGuido
What Has 57 Heads, 12 Controllers and 321 Editors? | Press Gazette

Find out more about PLMR AD-MS

Mandy Rice-Davies (R.I.P.) on Lord Astor’s denial of their affair….

“Well he would, wouldn’t he?”

Tip off Guido
Web Guido's Archives

Subscribe me to:


AddThis Feed Button

Guido Reads

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,646 other followers