August 31st, 2010

Guardian Falls Foul of Scott Trust

Further to the post earlier about the Guardian taking tens of thousands of pounds from local councils in return for editorial guidance over their review of the “Future of Public Services” Guido got thinking. Is this shabby journalism really what was envisaged by the tax-evading CP Scott? The Scott Trust is in place to “secure the financial and editorial independence of the Guardian in perpetuity: as a quality national newspaper without party affiliation; remaining faithful to its liberal tradition; as a profit-seeking enterprise managed in an efficient and cost-effective manner.” All very noble.

Amongst the “essential qualities that Scott believed should form the character of a newspaper” are honesty, fairness and “a sense of duty to the reader and the community”. The Scott Trust’ role is to ensure that these values are upheld throughout Guardian Media Group.

So how does touting out control over a feature to the highest bidder really stack up with this?

Perhaps a complaint to the Scott Trust is in order…


36 Comments

  1. 1
    Anonymous says:

    Do people still pay to read the Guardian?

    • 6
      Iraqi Orphan says:

      The BBC and other public bodies order vast numbers of The Guardian. This practice will have to stop in the current austere times.

    • 9
      Princess Pollytwaddle says:

      It is worth every penny to be allied with a quality national title that has high-value journalism produced by the likes of myself…

    • 11
      Princess Pollytwaddle says:

      Anyway, at least Guido has stopped putting up that bloody video of me getting slapped-down by Littlejohn…

    • 22
      Peter Grimes says:

      Better to complain to the Charity Commission than to the Scott Trust surely.

      Oh, I forgot, the CC is pure card-carrying ZaNuLieBor as well!

    • 24
      The Grim Reaper says:

      The ABC circulation figures shows a readership of 350,000. Take away the free subscriptions at every desk at the BBC, the teachers, social workers, Islamists, tree huggers, subsidy junkies, rich lefties in NW London and people only allowed to use crayons…..then the circulation is pathetic.

      Even better….stop all Government and Local Authority advertising and this dreadful rag will die……how about it Eric?

      And even Polly Twin Set may have to sell one of her many houses. Or is she just trying to keep us with fellow comrades like Lord Lardy of Two Jags or the Smirking Chancer’s Nine Properties?

  2. 2
    Charles Flaccidwidger says:

    Go for it, Guido.

  3. 3
    NotaSheep says:

    How long is it since The Guardian was a ‘quality national newspaper without party affiliation’? Surely it has been the Labour party house paper for many years now.

  4. 4
    Polly's Villa in Tuscany says:

    Taxes are for the little people…Pah!

    • 16
      Tony "war criminal" Blair, 10 houses and counting, slotgob on a spending spree as I write says:

      Fancy opening an account in my new bank? Super-rich only, of course, no serfs allowed.

      Keep working little people, your taxes are needed to fund my special protection squad so I can keep evading justice.

    • 19
      Seepy Snott says:

      Polly, you are an inspiration. Your radical left progessivity and intellectualism baffle the fat fool Fawkes. Thanks sister!

  5. 5
    tory boys never grow up says:

    Could all those who do not appreciate the irony of Guido lecturing the Guardian on journalistic ethics please go an look “hypocrisy” up in the dictionary.

    • 10
      Iraqi Orphan says:

      Could you be more specific? Do you support Labour murderers and torturers?

      • 34
        tory boys never grow up says:

        I don’t support any murderers or torturers. That is why I always opposed Sadaam Hussein and all his fascist friends – can you say the same??

    • 12
      concrete pump says:

      Fawkes’ site is ‘tittle tattle, gossip and rumours’, not journalism.

    • 13
      Polly's Villa in Tuscany says:

      I don’t think Guido has ever claimed to be a Journalist, or even claimed he had ethics….Much different from the do-as-I-say-not-as-I-do tax cheats and hypocrites at the Guardian. Especially that multi-millionaire ardent Socialist Polly…

  6. 7
    Peter Pickle says:

    Guardian journalists = human waste

    stop tinkering with peoples lives

    • 27
      Peter Grimes says:

      Look, if you mean ‘shit’, write it, not ‘human waste’!

      No one here of any merit will query you!

  7. 8
    Billy Bowden is the greatest umpire ever ! says:

    Until the media do there job properly the demise of newspapers will continue

  8. 14
    Tim Lovejoy says:

    Hi , My names Tim Lovejoy and i am a BBC legend who reads and agrees with everything Polly writes.

    Ps More money for the BBC so they can employ talant like me.

    Ker Ching !!!!

    • 35
      Sir Stuart Bell-End MP says:

      I see you’re getting the hang of it now, young man.

      I may allow you the use of my catchphrase- for a substantial royalty payment, of course!

      Ker-ching!!!!

  9. 21
    Tuscan Maid says:

    You should see the poo stripes she leaves in the bed

    i reckon a dab of swarfega would help

  10. 23
    Pete. says:

    Are there any hetero’s left in parlaiment?

  11. 29
    Anonymous says:

    Is there not a law that prevents politically motivated Marxists infecting, subverting and undermining the trust set up by this well-meaning chap ?

    Theft ?

  12. 31
    SaltPetre says:

    So if I understand correctly, Hague is a homosexual who puts his penis in other mens bottoms and vice-versa? If so, shouldn’t he be a Lib-Dem??

  13. 32
    Anonymous says:

    The Guardian long ago stopped even paying lip service to the Scott Trust’s stated aims.
    The modern Guardian is a pale shade of the Manchester Guardian as was…

  14. 33
    Ruth Kelly's plaything says:

    Today’s Grauniad isn’t worth reading except as a precautionary tale of how far a noble ideal may be perverted by those currently holding the reins.

    But that is VERY different from mocking the original aims of C P Scott (‘All very noble’ in your special acerbic red italics, Guido). If only Scott’s aims could be adhered to by his heirs and successors we would have a paper well worth reading – just as if the BBC rediscovered Reithian values their news and current affairs output would be worth listening to.

    OK, impossible dreams, both of them, given the corruption of public life evident everywhere today. But a man’s reach should exceed his grasp etc.

  15. 36



Another Twittish Tweet from Kerry McCarthy | BBC 
What’s the Point of Our Anti-Business Secretary? | Ruth Porter
HuffPo Hiring Pro-Iranian Mehdi “Act of Desperation” | Fox News
Krugman is Seductive, Simplistic and Unrealistic | Jeremy Warner
Lower Taxes, Higher Growth, the Statistical Evidence | CPS
Bash the Unions, Gatecrash the Quangos | ConservativeHome
I Told You So: Euro is Doomed | Douglas Carswell
PM Speaks for the Nation When Bashing Balls | Quentin Letts
Time for an Alliance | Dan Hannan
Farage’s Plan | ConservativeHome
Guardian Open News is a Failure | Heather Brooke
Balls Calls for Deeper Cuts | Speccie
Lessons from the Thirties | CPS
PMQs Idiots | Harry Cole
Jon Cruddas is Not the Messiah | Dan Hodges

Previously Seen


Peter Botting



Lord Lamont told ITV News…

“I think the PM is just human and Ed Balls is a pretty irritating person”



AC1 says:

Gangsters keep their promises, unlike party manifestos.



Tip off Guido
Web Guido's Archives








RSS


AddThis Feed Button
Archive


Labels
Guido Reads